Did the Phillies send down the wrong guy when activating Jay Bruce?

Phillies announce that they activated Jay Bruce from the 10-day injured list. To make room on the roster, Matt Klentak sent Adam Haseley down to Lehigh Valley. This move is a headscratcher for me as Haseley is one of the bright spots for the Phillies this season.

At the trade deadline, Klentak bolstered the Phillies bench by acquiring Corey Dickerson. The move was a good one as he adds a quality bat to the lineup. It was thought that by acquiring Dickerson, he and/or Bruce would be relegated to the bench as an extra bat. The move has many questioning why?

Phillies Send Down the Wrong Guy

I mean the Phillies are in a playoff race. So they chose to send down one of their better players. Haseley’s line is .274/.315/.452 with three homers and 12 RBI. What is more important is that Haseley is one of the few hitters driving in runs. He is currently hitting .353 with RISP, the best on the team. That with the fact his last ten games he has been amazing, hitting .333.

The Phillies had other options to send down and Haseley was not the top of my list. First would be Roman Quinn. The Phillies would have to put him on waivers. His asset is his speed, however, he is not a good major league hitter. His line is .195/.271/.322. However, he has no options remaining. The Phillies would have to put him on waivers. But let it sink in that Kapler and Klentak would rather keep a guy who they don’t bat before the pitcher over Haseley?

Other than Quinn, you have Sean Rodriguez and Brad Miller. The Phillies would have to designate him for assignment (DFA). Again to be sent down he would have to clear waivers. Rodriguez’s line is .229/.313/.400. As for Miller, he appears to have options remaining. Being an infielder, it makes sense to keep him on the roster, however, Miller isn’t producing. His line is .214/.360/.476.

The smart move would have been to send down Ranger Suarez and platoon both Bruce and Dickerson. That way the could have lept the right-handed bats of Rodriguez and Miller.

What’s the thought process?

This statement from Kapler doesn’t make sense. Haseley is playing every day for the Phillies and improving. So the Phillies make the decision to go with two players coming off of injuries instead of the surging Haseley? Haseley has the upside, he is the future. After a slow start, he is settling in and figuring out how to hit major league pitching.

So now the Phillies are going to start Dickerson, with a groin issue, at centerfield and Bruce, with an oblique issue in left. This doesn’t make any sense to me and it appears that neither Kapler, Klentak or MacPhail have a vision for the future. “It’s a bold strategy Cotton, let’s see if it pays off for him.”

Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports

12 thoughts on “Did the Phillies send down the wrong guy when activating Jay Bruce?

  1. This team is collapsing just like they did last year. Same inconsistent heating and pitching. They rarely come back to win any game they are trailing after 7 innings. Pitching and hitting coaches must be replaced for next season. Ron

  2. You overlooked the one main reason why they sent Haseley down. He would be a rookie that would be eligible for free agency one year sooner if they kept him up now.

    Dumbfounded question answered.

  3. I hate to see the kids go down, but come on your reasons are ridiculous. Quinn is too valuable to lose on waivers, and you can’t platoon 2 left handers. Hasely is the real deal, but he is the only one who can go down. They are left hand heavy now and Quinn can balance that a little. He’ll be back in a month.

  4. Kapler’s statement makes perfect sense Halsey has been playing regularly but with the return of Bruce, won’t be. Therefore he goes where he’ll get a lot of PAs (not here). Your argument here isn’t about who to send down, it’s about who to start.

    Once they decide not to start Halsey, sending him down is a foregone conclusion.

      1. I saw they sent him down by reading a quick byline on my TV, and now I turn the game on and he’s in the game?! I was worried they would send him down, just had a feeling that they would make that mistake. I’m not sure we really needed Bruce at all. He’s probably a great guy but why are we going out getting old guys ? He doesn’t look very in shape to me. Hope they see the light and keep Haseley on the roster. I guess Bruce is back on the injured list… shocker.

  5. the phils are demonstrating a remarkable lack of judgement in personnel.it seems this team is either vastly overrated or lacks the leadership to perform at the level expected. they didnt address their main issues in the offseason,Moustakis was available at third, Hamels as the lhp starter needed, their rotation would never compete with the Nats or mets but was ignored.

Leave a Reply