MLS Shield Watch: Will the race stay neck-and-neck after Leagues Cup break?

Union, MLS
Apr 24, 2021; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; The Supporters’ Shield Trophy sits on display before the game between Inter Miami CF and the Philadelphia Union at Talen Energy Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Ross-USA TODAY Sports

MLS is back, again. The league took a week off for the Leagues Cup group phase to play out, and now the chaos of the home stretch returns this weekend. Teams are revamping and retooling with the transfer window open as the calendar has moved to August. Can the teams at the top stay there through the end of a grueling summer?

Union, MLS
Apr 24, 2021; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; The Supporters’ Shield Trophy on display before the game between Inter Miami CF and the Philadelphia Union at Talen Energy Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Ross-USA TODAY Sports

MLS Supporters’ Shield Watch after Matchday 26

1st Place: Philadelphia Union– 50 points from 25 games played

The Philadelphia Union jumped back up to first place in the East and the Supporters’ Shield rankings after a come-from-behind win over Colorado on the last MLS matchday. After conceding in the first half, Tai Baribo equalized with 25 minutes left; Mikael Uhre then scored a brace in the game’s last minutes to secure all three points for Philly. Now they’re hoping to keep the ball rolling after not being involved in Leagues Cup.

Philly plays seven of its last nine games against teams outside the MLS contender status right now, starting this weekend with a game at home against Toronto. The Union is in the driver’s seat for the Shield, but not by much. If they want to win it, they have to beat the teams they’re “supposed to” beat. If they do that, we may see Philadelphia win its first Shield since 2020; if there are any slip-ups, we won’t.

  • Next MLS Match: vs Toronto FC | Saturday, August 9 | 7:30 pm EST

2nd Place: FC Cincinnati – 49 points from 25 games played

FC Cincinnati was a favorite to make a deep run in the League Cup; that dream was cut short this past week. After a big win over Monterrey in their first match, they drew, then lost a PK shootout to Juárez, and lost their final phase one matchup against Chivas. Four points and a GD of zero see them crash out as an average side in the tournament. Now, they will have all of their focus shift to MLS play.

FCC takes on a Charlotte side that also failed to make it out of Phase One of the League Cup. Both will be looking for bounce-back games, as both have something to prove in the remainder of the season. Charlotte has snuck into the top 10 of MLS, while Cincinnati is looking to jump back to the top of the leaderboard. Which will be able to get back to winning ways, and who might continue to falter?

  • Next MLS Match: vs Charlotte FC | Sunday, August 10 | 6 pm EST

3rd Place: Nashville SC – 47 points from 25 games played

Nashville is another team in the top five that was not a part of Leagues Cup this year. They are in the midst of a US Open Cup run, where they could host Philly in the Semifinals if the Union beat the Red Bulls this coming week. Nashville has lost two of its last four MLS matches, and this weekend it takes on St. Louis.


Nashville is in the thick of this Shield race, and like a few teams competing for the top spot, it will have midweek cup competitions to put effort into. Can they keep their strong 2025 going down the home stretch? That’s the question that is begging for an answer. This team is already overachieving, but now they’re looking to win silverware.

  • Next MLS Match: @ St. Louis City | Saturday, August 9 | 8:30 pm EST

4th Place: San Diego FC – 46 points from 25 games played


San Diego returns to MLS play to continue its Cinderella expansion season. It didn’t fare well at all in the League Cup, which it entered after Vancouver opted out of. Three points from three matches against Liga MX sides sees it return to league play with its tail between its legs.


This is still the best team in the West and only four points off the Shield. Realistically, this expansion side could compete for the Shield while holding down the West. They’ll look to do just that this weekend when they head to Sporting Kansas City.

  • Next MLS Match: @ Sporting Kansas City | Saturday, August 9 | 8:30 pm EST

5th Place: Vancouver Whitecaps – 45 points from 24 games played

Vancouver was supposed to be in Leagues Cup this year, but chose to focus on the Canadian Championship and Concacaf Champions Cup instead. This has led to a good break over the last few weeks for Vancouver as they look to rise back into Shield contention. They took a step in the right direction in their last MLS match, beating Kansas City 3-0, and now they look to build on that.

Vancouver’s chances will be improved by the addition of German legend Thomas Müller. He could be the lynchpin that gets the Whitecaps’ attack firing on all cylinders again. They are just one point off the top of the West and five points off the Shield lead. Can they make a late-season run with 10 games left to play?

  • Next MLS Match: @ San Jose Earthquakes | Saturday, August 9 | 10:30 pm EST
Union, MLS
CHESTER, PA – NOVEMBER 08: Philadelphia Union Midfielder Alejandro Bedoya (11) lifts up the 2020 Supporters Shield for the league’s regular season best record during the post game ceremonies after the Major League Soccer match between the New England Revolution and the Philadelphia Union on November 8, 2020, at Subaru Park in Chester, PA. (Photo by Gregory Fisher/Icon Sportswire)

Rounding out the top 10

With less than a third of the season to go, it is clear that there is a top eight in contention for the Supporters’ Shield. Minnesota, Columbus, and Miami could jump into the top five with wins and luck on their side. The final two spots of MLS’s top 10 will be filled by teams that will make the MLS Cup Playoffs but are not likely to make a run for the Shield.

  • 6th Place: Minnesota United – 44 points from 25 games played
  • 7th Place: Columbus Crew SC – 44 points from 25 games played
  • 8th Place: Inter Miami CF – 42 points from 22 games played
  • 9th Place: Orlando City SC – 41 points from 25 games played
  • 10th Place: Charlotte FC – 38 points from 25 games played

There are 11 weeks left of the MLS season, most top ten teams in contention for the Supporters’ Shield have nine games left. A few teams, Vancouver, Columbus, and Miami, all have at least one game in hand on the opposition. Here’s a look at the remaining schedules for the teams fighting for the Shield as we get ready for Matchday 28!

MLS
MLS Shield Watch – 9 games left

Be sure to return to Philly Sports Network for more Philadelphia Union and other soccer content!

Follow our Union team on Twitter:

Tim Lovenguth | Jimmy King | Paul Frenzel
Nate Tennesen | Eric Frysinger | Steve Beavon
Tomiwa Aderinoye | Christopher Babos | Liam Jenkins

Doop on Union fans!

Featured Image Credit: Kyle Ross-USA TODAY Sports